The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (2024)

How exactly did we rank the pizza in a city that claims to be the birthplace of America’s first-ever pies? A city where even the pigeons have slice preferences? First, we ate a lot of pizza. We revisited the classics, checked out the newcomers, and debated which spots best represent their genre. Pizza preference will always be deeply personal, so read through this list and find the pie that sounds right for you. Maybe it's a thick Detroit-style one with cheese-encrusted edges, maybe it's a perfect Neapolitan pizza with a pool of EVOO in the center, or maybe it's our personal favorite, the first pie on this list.


photo credit: Teddy Wolff

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (1)


L'Industrie Pizzeria




Perfect For:

Casual Weeknight DinnerCheap EatsImpressing Out of TownersKidsLunchQuick Eats

L’Industrie sets the standard for a great New York slice at both their original Williamsburg spot and larger location in the West Village. Each bit of blistered thin crust puffs, then crunches, tasting more and more like the loaf of bread you bought at the farmers market thanks to a long fermentation process. Minimal tomato sauce and spot-on oven temperatures ensure the layer of rich mozzarella stays perfectly in place, while a stream of orange grease drips down your wrist. The difference between this and most other slice shops is that L’Industrie prioritizes ingredients imported from Italy. Each slice is topped with giant basil leaves and grated parmesan, and toppings like velvety burrata, slightly sweet pepperoni, or soppressata. This is simply the best single slice in NYC.

photo credit: Teddy Wolff

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (2)





$$$$Perfect For:BYOBClassic EstablishmentImpressing Out of TownersLiterally Everyone

We could tell you about the way the pizzaiolo at this cash-only, BYOB restaurant rolls out the dough with empty wine bottles on a marble countertop in the candlelit dining room. But those details, along with the fact that eating at this Carroll Gardens institution requires lining up at 3pm, don’t matter for this guide. What matters is Lucali's thin New York-style pies, which have crunchy crusts, a serious sprinkle of minced garlic, and tomato sauce that’s a little sweet, a little tangy, and good enough to eat with a spoon. And yet it’s the piles of fresh basil that put the pizza here over the top—and make you feel the type of emotional connection your ex said you weren’t capable of.

photo credit: Emily Schindler

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (3)




$$$$Perfect For:Big GroupsBirthdaysCheap EatsKidsLiterally EveryoneOutdoor/Patio Situation

Going to L&B is a rite of passage, and if you haven’t made the trip out to Gravesend for a square slice, we don’t think you can really call yourself a New Yorker. This place has been around since 1938, with an over-the-top Rococo interior for sit-down meals, and an always-bustling outdoor seating area with grab-and-go windows for slices, sandwiches, and spumoni. Don’t bother with round pizza here, you want their signature sauce-on-top square that achieves textural perfection.

photo credit: Emily Schindler

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (4)


Una Pizza Napoletana


Lower East Side

$$$$Perfect For:Date NightCasual Weeknight DinnerEating At The BarImpressing Out of Towners

This is the sixth iteration of Una Pizza Napoletana, and we know exactly why this place won’t die. It’s serving the best Neapolitan pies in NYC—and possibly the world. Open three days a week, Una Pizza is now in a remodeled, candlelit room on the Lower East Side. Our go-to order is the margherita, but if you’re in the mood for something without sauce, try the bianca with anchovies and dip torn-off pieces of crust into the fishy and salty pool of olive oil that forms in the middle of the pie. Since all the pizzas have the same otherworldly crust, you can’t go wrong with whatever you order.

photo credit: Carina Finn

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (5)


Di Fara Pizza



$$$$Perfect For:Classic EstablishmentSerious Take-Out Operation

Di Fara opened in 1965, and they’ve been making legendary pies in their tiny South Brooklyn ever since. The late owner Dom DeMarco made the pizzas himself right behind the counter for most of that time, but now the pizza-making torch has been passed on to his family. The pizza here is still being prepared with several different kinds of cheese, olive oil, and plenty fresh basil. It has a crunchy crust that's notably salty, and each slice will offer a satisfying crackle as you fold it. One slice will make you incredibly happy, and a second will make you want to get into a sleeping bag and watch a rom-com.

photo credit: Noah Devereaux

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (6)





$$$$Perfect For:BirthdaysCasual Weeknight DinnerDining SoloEating At The BarFirst/Early in the Game DatesWalk-Ins

Ops perfected their sourdough long before everyone jumped on the naturally leavened dough-train. Each time we eat here, their wood-fired pizzas seem to get tangier. In terms of style, Ops’ pies fit somewhere between crispy New York and soppy-in-the-middle Neapolitan: each slice remains straight when you hold it in the air, but the crust puffs up like a balloon. Truthfully it doesn’t matter what you call the style. What matters is that you’re going to want to come to their dimly lit, sexy sourdough pizza emporium in Bushwick every week, like you owe them starter money.

photo credit: Nitzan Rubin

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (7)


Paulie Gee's Slice Shop



$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerQuick Eats

The greatest places to grab a slice are generally not establishments where you want to stay and hang for a while. Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop is different though. It’s a counter-service spot that looks like a neighborhood pizza parlor from the 1970s, and it’s where you’ll find some excellent, foldable New York-style slices with crust that’s equal parts chewy and crispy. Their Hellboy slice—with hot honey and spicy pepperoni—is one of the finest things in New York City that you can purchase for $5, and their garlicky white slice (The Mootz) proves that several layers of rich cheese and a drizzle of olive oil can do just fine without tomato sauce.

photo credit: Emily Schindler

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (8)


Mama's Too


Upper West Side

$$$$Perfect For:Quick Eats

We once went to Mama’s Too to eat their gas-oven Sicilian squares when it was 15 degrees outside. We had to wear pants under our pants, and it was 100% worth it. That was the first time we tried their mushroom pie as well as the cacio e pepe pizza with its four types of cheese and cracked black pepper—both of which will enrich your life in ways you have yet to fathom. And those aren’t even the best slices here. The square pepperoni is worth a trip across the city, and the house triangular slice with fresh basil is just about as noteworthy as the one at Di Fara. This tiny counter-service spot on the UWS has already become an NYC classic. They also have a second location in the West Village.

photo credit: Kate Previte

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (9)


Amore Pizzeria



$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerClassic EstablishmentImpressing Out of Towners

We tried to get an employee at this Flushing spot to tell us the secret to their pizza. They gave us a one-word answer: consistency. Open since the 1970s, this fluorescent-lit shop is still churning out simple, perfect New York-style pies for a steady stream of customers. Stop by for a whole cheese pizza, or try to snag a slice fresh from the oven. The crust is thin and crispy with a little bit of chew, the sauce is thick and not-too-sweet, and the hefty layer of cheese on top is bright orange with grease. Grab a table in the small, barebones space so you can eat your pizza as soon as it exits the oven.

photo credit: David A Lee

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (10)


Scarr's Pizza


Lower East Side

$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerFeeling Hot



The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (11)

It’s almost impossible to resist the gravitational pull of Scarr’s, both because of the hypebeast-y LES crowd that lingers out front, and because a Scarr’s slice will make you want to investigate how crust can taste so flavorful. Part of the reason the pizza is so good: Scarr’s mills their own grains in-house. Browned cheese blankets the surface of the slightly yeasty crust, with a zesty tomato sauce underneath. Stick with thin-crust slices, as we’ve found the square slices to be inconsistent, and you’re in for the best pizza you can find on the LES.

photo credit: Liz Clayman

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (12)


Wizard Hat Pizza


Prospect Lefferts Gardens

$$$$Perfect For:Literally Everyone

Wizard Hat Pizza thinks it’s okay if you dip your pizza in ranch. We know that might anger some pizza purists, but we'd encourage them to try. A bite of Wizard Hat’s pizza dipped in their tangy buttermilk ranch has the power to alter the brain chemistry of anti-ranch-on-pizza New Yorkers permanently. The naturally leavened pies are crispy, chewy, and showered in basil—and in an ideal world, you'd have stomach space for all seven variations.Try the spicy pepperoni first, and get a caesar salad. This pop-up is now operating regularly out of a space in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, and we’d recommend ordering ahead for same-day pick-up, so that you can eat at least one hot slice on the sidewalk.

photo credit: Kate Previte

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (13)


Mano's Pizzeria



$$$$Perfect For:Serious Take-Out Operation

Mano’s is not just a classic New York slice, but a classic New York slice shop as well. There are no servers. There’s no natural wine. If you pop in for lunch, there won’t be a tour group clogging the entrance. The Ridgewood establishment sports a standard-issue Italian flag awning, and it’s home to a perfect cheese pie with a thin layer of mozz that commingles with a simple tomato sauce, becoming one. There are, however, some fancy elements at work. The dough is fermented for days—resulting in a thin, crunchy crust—and the toppings range from garlic aioli and cracked black pepper to sweet caramelized onions swimming in provolone.

photo credit: Alex Staniloff

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (14)




Red Hook

$$$$Perfect For:Date NightCasual Weeknight Dinner

We could subsist on pepperoni slices from our favorite slice shops for the rest of our lives, easily. But if your Friday pizza night is in need of a refresh, might we suggest a pork belly and bottarga-topped pizza under the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway? At Farina, a Southern Italian restaurant on the border of Carroll Gardens and Red Hook, the “irregolare” pizzas are slightly heftier than a classic Neapolitan, smaller than regular pies, and topped with things like apricot jam and mashed potatoes. Funkily shaped and perfectly charred, they come with chewy, blistered crusts, and are best shared with a group after a full day Red Hook excursion, along with some house wine.

photo credit: Teddy Wolff

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (15)


Ace's Perfect Pizza



$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerImpressing Out of TownersLunchSerious Take-Out Operation

Ace’s in Williamsburg makes the best Detroit-style pizza in the city. Their shop might look like any old slice joint, but it’s somewhere you can hang out, sip some wine or beer, and play Mario Kart on N64. While they also do Sicilian pies and slices, your first move at Ace’s should unquestionably be some iteration of Detroit-style. Keep it simple, and get your pizza topped with pepperoni—and if you’re with one other person, order a small. You’ll get four airy slices with a crispy cheese-webbed crust that will fill you with profound joy.

photo credit: Lucia Pizza of Avenue X

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (16)


Lucia Pizza of Avenue X


Sheepshead Bay

$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerLunchQuick Eats

If you want to eat at Lucia Pizza in Sheepshead Bay five days a week, that sounds like a fine idea, and we aren’t going to stop you. Just make sure that one of those days is Friday. That’s when you can try the clam pie, a weekly special made with chopped cherry stones, translucent cross-sections of garlic, and a white wine butter reduction. Like the rest of the pies at this retro-inspired slice joint, it has a thin, crisp, slightly chewy crust that’s puffy around the edges like a fresh-made zeppole. Squeeze a lemon wedge over the top, and enjoy. The slice with whipped ricotta and crumbled local Italian sausage is another box to check, and the spinach with bechamel is highly underrated. Lucia Pizza has a newer location in Soho, though that one doesn’t have any seating.

photo credit: Brendan Edwards

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (17)




$$$$Perfect For:LunchCasual Weeknight DinnerKidsQuick EatsVegans

This Bed-Stuy spot sets itself apart from other slice shops by offering a bunch of uncommon toppings. You’ll see varieties like chicken and waffle, shrimp alfredo with black truffle, and lasagna, but the oxtail pies are the main attraction. There are three different kinds, and the sweet chili one comes loaded with crispy, tender shredded oxtail. The chewy crust will remind you of a buttermilk biscuit (in taste, not texture), and it’s a good, understated vehicle for all the aggressively-flavored toppings. Most people get their food to go, but there are a couple of tables and a counter for standing. Lines often snake out the door, so it’s a good idea to get here early. They have a new location in Queens, which we hear is just as busy.

photo credit: Noah Devereaux

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (18)


Staten Island

$$$$Perfect For:Big GroupsCasual Weeknight DinnerClassic EstablishmentKids

You might think that Rubirosa is the only place that makes a super-thin-crust pie with excellent vodka sauce. News flash: Rubirosa borrows their recipes and style from legendary Staten Island spot Joe & Pat's. (The owner of Rubirosa is related to the team who started Joe & Pat's.) The crust here is almost as thin as matzoh, so we don’t recommend weighing it down with more than one topping. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing. It just means you can eat more cracker-thin pizza, which you will inevitably want to do. If you don’t live on Staten Island, this old-school restaurant is worth the trip, but there's also a location in the East Village.

photo credit: Willa Moore

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (19)



Pelham Bay

$$$$Perfect For:Impressing Out of TownersClassic EstablishmentOutdoor/Patio Situation

This pizza spot opened in East Harlem in the 1947, then moved into a tiny brick building on the first floor of a house in Pelham Bay about a decade later. We don’t know who lives in that house, but we hope they get Louie & Ernie’s New York-style pizza as often as their digestive tract allows. Whether you order a whole pie or a slice on a paper plate, be sure to get your pizza with crumbly-salty sausage on top. Like the pies at NYC’s best old-school spots, these edges crisp up while the middle stays soft.

photo credit: Kate Previte

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (20)


Patsy's Pizza


East Harlem

$$$$Perfect For:Classic EstablishmentKidsQuick Eats

This pizza looks like the results of a Google image search of “NYC pizza.” But if you called it ordinary, that would be very wrong. Patsy's uses a coal oven, which gives each slice a heavy char, and they claim to have invented the concept of selling pizza by the slice in the 1930s. When you’re at the original location, though, it doesn’t matter if you’re getting a whole pie or just a slice from the counter. What does matter is that you’ll need to order the plain. It’s thin and soft but holds up the bright red sauce and big circles of mozzarella.

photo credit: Emily Schindler

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (21)





$$$$Perfect For:Big GroupsDate NightFirst/Early in the Game DatesGluten-Free OptionsLiterally Everyone

Rubirosa is one of Manhattan’s top Italian restaurants, and they've earned this distinction almost purely due to the quality of their pizza. In addition to serving perfect Staten Island-style, crackery crust pies, they also have gluten-free pizza that's somehow just as good. Whichever route you go, prioritize the vodka-sauce and tie-dye varieties. Reservations at this dark, bustling Nolita restaurant are inevitably tough to get, but you can always stop by and put your name in for a table. You'll probably have to wait for an hour or two before you're seated, but consider that time an investment into your happiness and wellbeing.

photo credit: Noah Devereaux

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (22)

Lee's Tavern

Bar Food

Staten Island

$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerClassic EstablishmentLunchSports!

Lee’s Tavern feels like it’s frozen in an era before cell phones were invented. Every table at this 1940s-founded sports bar on Staten Island features at least one pitcher of light beer and a couple of thin-crust pizzas oozing cheese onto paper plates. The pies here are some of our favorite in the Staten-Island style, with slightly charred bottoms and crust bubbles you could break with a single little tap. Always order the clam pie, even if you were raised to think that mollusks and cheese don’t belong together. The mild, low-moisture cheese, fresh hunks of garlic, and briny clams work so well together that they should form an LLC.

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC - New York - The Infatuation (2024)


Who makes the best pizza in NYC? ›

Best New York pizza
  1. Di Fara Pizza. Pizza. Midwood. price 2 of 4. ...
  2. Lucali. Pizza. Carroll Gardens. price 2 of 4. ...
  3. L&B Spumoni Gardens. Pizza. Gravesend. price 2 of 4. ...
  4. Joe's Pizza. Pizza. West Village. ...
  5. Ops. Pizza. Bushwick. ...
  6. Scarr's Pizza. Pizza. Lower East Side. ...
  7. Trattoria Zero Otto Nove. Italian. The Bronx. ...
  8. Roberta's. Pizza. East Williamsburg.
Apr 11, 2023

What is the number one pizza place in the United States? ›

CHICAGO (WGN) — A Chicago favorite has taken the top spot in Yelp's 2024 list of the 100 best pizza places in the United States. Pequod's Pizza, located at 2207 North Clybourn Avenue, was voted No. 1 — most likely thanks to their famous caramelized cheese crust on its pan-style pizza.

What are the top pizza chains? ›

12 Best Pizza Franchises in the USA
  • Domino's. Since 1960, Domino's has grown to become one of the most recognized and leading pizza franchise brands in the world. ...
  • Pizza Hut. ...
  • Papa John's. ...
  • Little Caesars. ...
  • Papa Murphy's. ...
  • Hunt Brothers. ...
  • Marco's Pizza. ...
  • Blaze Pizza.
Mar 28, 2024

How much is a slice of pizza in NYC? ›

The results are in: according to Quigley's analysis, the average price of a plain slice in NYC increased from $2.52 in 2014 to $3 by the end of 2022, a 16% rise. As noted by the reporter himself on his website, the calculation excludes dollar slices and does not function as any sort of ranking by deliciousness.

Where do the Kardashians eat pizza in NYC? ›

TikTok. Kim Kardashian is obsessed with this. pizza place called joe's Pizza, so I had to order some to see if it's worth the hype.

What is the number one pizza restaurant in the world? ›

In tied in first place are Italian pizzerias I Masanielli by Francesco Martucci, in Caserta, and 10 Diego Vitagliano by Diego Vitagliano, in Naples. In second place was Anthony Mangieri's Una Pizza Napoletana in New York, while third place went to Rafa Panatieri and Jorge Sastre's Sartoria Panatieri, in Barcelona.

What is the #1 pizza chain in America? ›


What is the most loved pizza? ›

This may not come as a surprise, but pepperoni is by far the most popular pizza topping in the United States.

Why is NYC pizza so good? ›

New York–style pizza gets its distinguishing crust from the high-gluten bread flour with which it is made. Minerals present in New York City's tap water supply are also credited with giving the dough in metro area pies its characteristic texture and flavor.

What do New Yorkers call a slice of pizza? ›

into any pizzeria in the city, make eye contact with the guy behind the counter, utter the word “slice,” and within seconds there'll be what you out-of-towners or newbies might call a “piece of cheese pizza” sitting on a paper plate before you. Oh, you want an entire pizza, eh? Well, that's a “pie”.

What is traditional New York pizza? ›

New York-style pizza has slices that are large and wide with a thin crust that is foldable yet crispy. It is traditionally topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, with any extra toppings placed on top of the cheese. Pizza without additional toppings is called “plain,” “regular,” or “cheese.”

What is the most popular type of pizza in New York? ›

NY Style Pizza

The most common and now quintessential form of NY pizza has thus become the type that is cooked in gas ovens rather than the Neapolitan-American type cooked with coal. NY style pizza is sold either as whole pies or by the "slice" — a triangular wedge cut from a whole pizza.

Who owns best pizza NY? ›

Best Pizza was opened in the winter of 2010 by pizzaman Frank Pinello. Located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn in a former bakery, Best Pizza utilizes a century-old, wood-burning oven to turn out some of the best slices in town.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 5738

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.